Declined is not the last word.
A record of matters we have carried past a first decision — to the Tribunal, to the Ombudsman, and back to Immigration New Zealand. Depersonalised, and told for what they show about how a case is rebuilt.
Every decision has a next forum.
Depending on the visa and where you applied from, a decision can be reconsidered, appealed, reviewed, complained about or put to the Minister. Select a forum to see the matters we have taken there.
Which forum is open depends on the visa type, where the application was made and strict time limits. Some decisions carry no right of review at all — verify current criteria before acting.
Matters we have taken further.
Every case here is a real matter. Names and identifying details are removed or changed. What remains is the decision, the flaw in it, and what we did.
A Skilled Migrant residence decline, set aside on appeal.
INZ declined a Skilled Migrant residence application on health grounds. We appealed: nothing explained why a family member's support needs amounted to full-time care — the finding that ruled out a medical waiver.
Decline cancelled and returned to INZ for a fresh assessment by a different officer.
Read the case notes
Immigration and Protection Tribunal
General experience with other people is not evidence of this person's care needs — and nothing else on the file supported a finding of full-time care.
The decision
Immigration New Zealand concluded that a family member included in the application did not meet the residence health standard. It also decided that the family member required full-time care, including care in the community — a finding that made them ineligible to be considered for a medical waiver.
What we found
A medical report already on file indicated that the family member was expected to need periodic support. The medical assessor relied instead on general experience with people likely to qualify for specialist education funding, without explaining how that experience supported a finding of full-time care in this individual case.
What we did
We appealed to the Immigration and Protection Tribunal, challenging the finding that barred our client from being considered for a medical waiver. We brought together the clinical and educational evidence already on file to show what the family member could manage independently, where support was needed, and why the medical report anticipated only periodic support.
We put a direct question to the Tribunal: what evidence supported the conclusion that this person required full-time care? The assessor's general experience with others did not answer it, nor explain why the medical opinion in this case had been set aside. We asked the Tribunal to cancel the decline and direct a fresh, evidence-based assessment of eligibility for a medical waiver.
The outcome
The Tribunal found that Immigration New Zealand had failed to take relevant evidence into account and to give adequate reasons for its decision on waiver eligibility. It directed a different immigration officer to reassess the application, with an opportunity for the applicant to provide updated evidence. Waiver eligibility and the residence application itself remain to be determined.
Why it matters
Meeting the residence health standard and qualifying for consideration of a medical waiver are separate questions. A finding that someone requires full-time care must rest on evidence of that person's own care needs.
Two visitor visa declines, taken to the Ombudsman.
An offshore family was twice refused visitor visas on bona fides grounds. We complained that the decisions were unreasonable and drew on an unrelated file.
INZ agreed a fresh application, assessed on its own merits.
Read the case notes
Office of the Ombudsman
Once the Ombudsman engaged, INZ agreed a remedy — a fresh application, assessed on its own merits.
The decision
Two visitor visa applications for a family living outside New Zealand were declined in succession. Each time, INZ was not satisfied the family were genuine visitors who would leave on time.
What we found
The reasoning leaned on information that belonged to an unrelated file, gave little weight to strong ties to the family's home country, and applied the visitor instructions more narrowly than their terms allow. With no right of appeal offshore, the usual routes were closed.
What we did
After INZ's internal complaints process did not resolve the matter, we prepared a formal complaint to the Chief Ombudsman, setting out how the decisions were unreasonable and why the process had been unfair.
The outcome
Following the Ombudsman's involvement, INZ agreed a remedy that allowed a fresh application to be lodged and assessed afresh.
Why it matters
Where there is no right of appeal, the Ombudsman can still examine whether an agency acted reasonably and fairly. A well-built complaint can reopen a door that looked shut.
A declined application, reopened offshore.
An offshore temporary visa decline carried no right of reconsideration or appeal. We showed INZ the decision rested on an error that could not fairly stand.
Reassessed afresh — no new application, no months of delay.
Read the case notes
Immigration New Zealand
INZ accepted the error and reopened the application for a fresh decision — sparing our client a new application and the months that come with it.
The decision
A temporary visa application made from overseas was declined. Because it was lodged offshore, there was no right to ask for reconsideration and no right of appeal.
What we found
The decline turned on a point that the file itself contradicted. The error was material: without it, the reasons for declining fell away.
What we did
We wrote to INZ with a focused request to reopen, identifying the error, pointing to the evidence on file, and explaining why the decision could not fairly stand.
The outcome
INZ agreed to reopen the application and reassess it, rather than leaving our client to start again from the beginning.
Why it matters
No formal review right does not mean no remedy. A precise, well-evidenced request can correct an error at the source.
A character concern, answered in full.
INZ put prejudicial information to a residence applicant about an included family member. We tested it, supplied the missing context and met the instructions point by point.
Resolved on the response alone — no waiver needed.
Read the case notes
Immigration New Zealand
The concern was resolved on the response alone — no waiver was needed.
The decision
Before deciding a residence application, INZ wrote to the applicant with potentially prejudicial information about a family member included in the application.
What we found
The information was incomplete and, read in context, did not engage the character instructions in the way INZ had assumed.
What we did
We prepared a response that tested each item of information, supplied documentary context, and addressed the relevant instructions point by point.
The outcome
INZ accepted the response and approved the application.
Why it matters
A PPI letter is an invitation to be heard. How it is answered often decides the case.
A role misclassified, corrected on response.
An employer's job check was challenged as a lower-skilled occupation. We evidenced the role's real duties against the ANZSCO task descriptors.
INZ accepted the higher classification.
Read the case notes
Immigration New Zealand
INZ accepted that the role met the higher classification.
The decision
INZ issued a request for information proposing to classify an employer's role under a lower-skilled occupation.
What we found
The proposed classification reflected the job title, not the work actually done or the business structure the role sat within.
What we did
We mapped the role's duties against the ANZSCO descriptors and supported each with operational evidence from the business.
The outcome
INZ accepted the higher classification and approved the job check.
Why it matters
Classification is evidence-led. The right evidence, framed against the descriptors, changes the answer.
A partner visa refusal, remitted on review.
A partner visa was refused on doubts the relationship was genuine. We sought merits review with fresh evidence from those who knew the couple best.
Decision set aside and remitted for reconsideration.
Read the case notes
Administrative Review Tribunal
The Tribunal was satisfied the relationship was genuine and continuing.
The decision
The Department refused a partner visa, finding it was not satisfied the relationship was genuine and continuing.
What we found
The delegate had given weight to gaps that fresh evidence could readily close, and little weight to the couple's shared life.
What we did
We applied for merits review at the Administrative Review Tribunal, with new evidence, statutory declarations and focused submissions.
The outcome
The Tribunal set the decision aside and remitted the application for reconsideration.
Why it matters
Merits review looks at the case afresh. New evidence, properly presented, can carry it.
No case is published for this forum yet — but we act there. Tell us about your decision.
Book a decision review →We read a decision the way a tribunal will.
- 01
Diagnose
We obtain the full file and read the decision against the law and instructions that actually applied — not the ones assumed.
- 02
Find the flaw
A misread instruction, unweighed evidence, an unfair process, an unreasonable conclusion. We locate the error that matters.
- 03
Choose the forum
Reconsideration, appeal, review, complaint or intervention — chosen on the visa, the deadline and where you are.
- 04
Build the record
Submissions, evidence and statements assembled so the next decision-maker has every reason to say yes.
Strategy is what turns a maybe into a yes.
After a decline.
My visa was declined. Can I appeal?
How long do I have?
Can you take on a case another adviser handled?
Do these cases mean my case will succeed?
Are these real cases?
The cases in this journal are illustrative. Each describes a real matter, depersonalised to protect client confidentiality, and some details have been changed. Every case turns on its own facts — no outcome is guaranteed, and past results do not predict future ones. Immigration settings change; verify current criteria before acting.
Had a decision go against you? Let's read it together.
Bring us the letter. A senior licensed adviser will tell you, in confidence, where it is weak and what can be done.